The 1870 Invasion
The three years of quiet was broke by the start of the Franco-Prussian War in the summer of 1870. After the Battle of Mentana, Napoleon III kept a garrison of 4,000 soldiers in Cività Vecchia. However, his war with Prussia was not going well, and he was getting desperate. He recalled the force in Rome and declared he was returning to the rules of the September convention. On September 2, Napoleon III was captured after his defeat at the Battle of Sedan. With France out of the way and Austria too weak to assist the Papal States, Victor Emmanuel II pounced on the opportunity. Afraid of having Garibaldi invade and risk destabilizing his monarchy, Victor Emmanuel II decided to use his Royal Army to invade Rome.
When word got out that the Italians were threatening Rome again, many former Papal Zouaves rushed back to Rome to come to the defense of the Holy Father. Included in those was future American Congressman Charles Tracey from New York. A second generation Irish American, Charles had grown up in Albany in a pius and influential family. When the news of the victory of Mentana broke Charles felt compelled to render his aid to the Holy Father. The 20 year old Charles joined the Zouaves at the end of 1867 and served with them periodically through the fall of 1869. He returned to New York and joined his father and brother in leading the family distillery business.
Keeping up to date with the events through the newspapers, Charles realized how dire the situation was and left for Rome in late August to rejoin his comrades. He went “as fast as rail and sail” could take him. While he was on his way Victor Emmanul II began his invasion. On September 9, the Royal Army posed themselves on the Lazio's border. Victor Emmanuel II wrote Bl. Pope Pius IX a letter and sent Count Gustavo Ponza di San Martino to deliver it the following day on September 10. The letter, which really was just a guise to request a bloodless takeover, claimed that due to the removal of French troops from the city, it was necessary for his forces to occupy the Eternal City so that they could maintain law and order from Roman revolutionaries. A strange thing to say since there were no revolutionary uprisings in Rome at the time. Bl. Pius IX did not appreciate the hypocrisy in the letter. He replied to Count Ponza. “What a race of vipers! Whited sepulchers! and wanting in faith!” Count Ponza became so afraid that he rushed out of the room and mistook a window for a door, almost falling to his death. Bl. Pius IX refused to be bullied. He rejected Victor Emmanuel II's offer, an action which certainly would lead to war, one which would be very difficult. The Italian Army had over 75,000 troops stationed on the frontier ready for action, meanwhile the Papal Army had only around 12,000 men.
After Count Ponza left, General Kanzler alongside his chief of staff, Major Rivolta, went to see Bl. Pius IX. to discuss the plans for defense. When he finished his brief, Bl. Pius IX. said “I am going to have to disappoint the army. It will have to surrender.” General Kanzler was shocked, Bl. Pius IX. explained that he did not want to lead Rome into death and destruction and leave that behind as his legacy. He wanted the army, upon invasion, to fall back onto Rome. However, bits of resistance were allowed on the way to show the world that the temporal power was being taken by force. General Kanzler, was upset at the decision, he protested and tried to persuade the Pope to allow his men to fight and die, he told him “the entire army from the highest officer to the most humble soldier wants to fight and die.” Bl. Pius IX. remained firm in his decision and responded “We choose to surrender, not to die is sometimes the bigger sacrifice.”
The Italians began their invasion on September 11. The Papal Army put up some resistance but started to fall back to Rome on the Pope's orders, the one exception being Cività Vecchia, the Papal port just north of Rome, so that the Pope could have a potential route to escape if needed. Meanwhile, Charles was still enroute to the Holy City, the fastest way was through Cività Vecchia. Instead of taking a French steamer to the city which was typical, he elected to through Germany by train. Due to their war with France, the German military was regularly seizing passenger trains. This caused his baggage to be delayed, rather than suffer a delay himself, Charles abandoned his things and proceeded to Cività Vecchia. However, when Charles arrived on September 16, he found that the port city had just surrendered
Bl. Pius IX had updated his surrender orders. The Holy City needed to be surrendered “at the first cannon shots.” And Cività Vecchia given up immediately. The Papal forces had just left when Charles arrived and the Italian General Bixio occupied the city. Charles was unsure of what do to, he spent the night at the Hotel Orlando. The following day while outside on the steps of the hotel he saw his friend Patrick Keye's O'Clery were re-united with him. O'Clery, a former Irish Zouave had served together with Charles in 1868. He had also arrived on the 16th and had found another fellow who wanted to join the Papal Zouaves, Englishman John George Kenyon. The trio found one more gentleman to join their crew, Charles Hemans, a now Roman resident of many years, writer, and correspondent for various London papers.
O'Clery revealed to Charles he was tasked with a special mission. On his journey back to Rome O'Clery had stopped in the papal consul in Marseilles. There he was given important letters and dispatches by the Consul General for the Cardinal Secretary of State and various papal military leaders, to smuggle back to Rome. The Italians had cut off all communication from the city so these documents were vital. O'Clery and Kenyon had heard that Bixio was supposed to set out dawn the following day to Rome, they believed this large movement of troops would cause enough confusion where they would be able make a break for the open country and make it to Rome before the Italian forces arrived.
The group decided to spend the night at the Orlando and find a carriage to take them to Rome in the early hours the following morning. That night, after everyone in the hotel had gone to sleep, Tracey and O'Clery stayed up went through the papers O'Clery had received. They figured the packet of papers was too bulky and they needed to reduce its size so that they could conceal it easier if they ran into Italian authorities. They burned any papers they deemed unnecessary, and took the remaining papers and letters and bundled them up in a smaller packet and put it away in a satchel.
The following morning, Bixio set off with his 20,000 men, the group found a driver who as only willing to take them as far as Palo which was about 25 miles away, they agreed and off they went. Through it was slow going and they were stopped frequently, they made it to Palo. There they came across the Italian army and, wondering what two Englishmen, an Irishman, and American were doing so close to their maneuvers, were placed under arrest. The group was brought before General Bixio himself.
General Bixio angrily turned toward the group and demanded that they hand over their passports and tell them where they intended on going. They answered truthfully that they intended on going to Rome. However, they concealed the fact that they were going so they could defend the city from his army. Instead, they claimed they were newspaper men, which was another half-truth since Hermans was one. He informed that they were not allowed to go until the city was taken by his forces and their rule was established. O'Clery described the situation further:
[General Bixio] muttered something about sending us back to Cività Vecchia, and then suddenly apologizing for his rudeness of manner, he invited us to join his mess. And enter Rome with his troops. As Pontifical Zouaves we could not allow ourselves to be under a compliment to one of Garibaldi's lieutenants, so we declined his offer with thanks, preferring to take up our quarters for the night in the deserted albergo (inn) at Palo, in front of which Piedmontese gendarmes were subsequently posted, doubles to take care of us.
The situation was not ideal, Kenyon said that “We had to sleep all together in a little dirty room, the whole place being full of Piedmontese.” Charles said of their predicament “This did not suit us at all. We were eager to join the zouaves in order to take part inf the defense of the Holy City and determined to try to get through the Italians lines.” The next morning on the 19th, the group found another driver to take them closer to Rome. They followed the Piedmontese again and overtook their rear-guard. The Italian movement was called to a halt, the group kept continuing forward until they found themselves faced to face with General Bixio again, who seemed in no enviable mood, pacing to and fro on the roadway.
Bixio, frustrated to see them again asked “Why press on so eagerly with my army?”
The group responded “Our desire to be present at the operations”
Bixio shouted back at them:
But this is a war, a war! Your place on the march is at the rear and not in the midst of my troops. You enjoy the excitement of war? It's a small matter now. Those pet lions, the Zouaves, know how to fight; arising in the streets, we will place them between two fires! Their destruction is inevitable, as their presence in Rome is a menace and a danger to Italian patriots.
The persistence of the group however, caused General Bixio to acquis to their demands. He granted them permission to continue as far as his advanced post which was about two miles in front of them. He warned them to not pass through the lines, doing so would be out their own peril. The group continued, upon reaching the advanced line, a gathering of dragoons and bersaglieri posted near a ruined osteria told them to stop. The officer in command of the detachment of troops told the group that they should remain here and not proceed any further. Which O'Clery described as “another way of saying we were under arrest.”
This obstacle did not deter the small group of Papal Zouaves. Determined to carry on, they conceived a plan to fool the Italian soldiers holding them captive and escape. They asked the officers of the Italian detachment if they could get a better sight of Rome by climbing the heights just above the road. They left behind their luggage in the carriage with the exception of the satchel with papers and letters, in an effort to persuade the soldiers that they would be right back. The Italians bought the ruse, they made no objections and allowed the group to climb to the top, once there, Tracey, O'Clery, Kenyon, and Hermans discussed their next step:
Here we held a council in full view of the Piedmontese; the dragoons, with the exception of those acting as lookouts, were lounging in the shade, their horses picketed close by, our coachman was consoling himself with some water, the only thing to be had. Both my friends, Messrs. Tracey and Kenyon, through fully aware that the seizure of the dispatches would necessarily involve their fate in mine if captured, like true Zouaves unhesitatingly declared their readiness to accompany me at all hazards. At that moment, catching a glimpse of St. Peter's glorious dome in the distance, we could no longer brook delay, as we were only twelve miles from the Eternal City, and had given no parole to the Piedmontese. Turning the crest on the hill we descended rapidly and keeping along the valley, made a detour to avoid the road, as the dragoons cannot easily follow across country. Soon we left Bixio's army far behind us. Mile after mile we hurry on gaining fresh impulse at every step, as we see St. Peter's more and more clearly defined, towering in all its majesty against the sky. Not a sound disturbs the awful stillness which reigns around; it would indeed seem as if the world stood still before the commission of the dreadful crime on the morrow! But it is the calm which portends the storm; ere many hours elapse the cannonade will thunder far across the Campagne and make the shepherds cower in their huts on the slopes of the hills. On and on we press with an ardor fast becoming a fever of excitement, to reach the goal of our hopes, utterly regardless of the danger o falling in with Cadorna's cavalry scouts endeavoring to cut off communications with the devoted city.
After hours of travel, the group finally reached the Eternal City, arriving around 4 p.m., well ahead of the Italian forces. “Deo Gratias,” thought Kenyon “the yellow and white flag was still waving.” The Zouaves were enthusiastic that some of their former comrades had returned to help in the defense. They were quickly taken into the city. O'Clery summed up their feelings “Our hearts were full of gratitude for the privilege so signally accorded to us of being able to join our comrades before the assault.” Hermans at this point separated from the group. He wanted to remain just outside the city in order to observe the fight so he could report to his contacts in the London papers.
Once inside O'Clery handed off the papers himself to Cardinal Antonelli at the Vatican and the other papers he gave to Colonel Allet at the Zouave head-quarters on the Pincio. He was very happy to see some of his former Zouaves. O'Clery wrote that:
Our brave old commander welcomed us back to the corps with all that kindness of manner which has so endeared him to hearts of the Zouaves. As no news had reached the city for several days we reported to the affair at Civita Vecchia, the advance of Bixio's army, and the certainty of an attack on Rome next morning.
Tracey, Kenyon, and O'clery joined over 8,500 Papal soldiers who had made it inside the city during the general withdraw. The city was now surrounded by over 60,000 Italian soldiers, including a large contingent of Red Shirts who came to wreak havoc on the city.