Battle of Castelfidardo

The Story of the Papal Zouaves

The violent fall of the Papal States and the unification of Italy is a much-overlooked period of history. Even more overlooked are the brave Papal Soldiers who sacrificed their lives for the cause of the Church. This is the story of the Papal Zouaves — the men who came from across Christendom to defend the Pope and his rights.

Map of Italy in 1859 showing the divided peninsula before unification
Map of the Italian Peninsula prior to Sardinia-Piedmont's forced unification

19th Century Italy

There was a time when the Pope ruled over most of central Italy. Given by Pepin the Short in 754, the Pope's temporal power was called the Papal States. For over 1000 years the Papal States helped secure the sovereignty of the Church, while at times contested and not always sufficient to prevent temporal interference into the affairs of the Church. Nonetheless, the Papal States served as an effective bulwark of the City of God against the City of Man. Without a temporal power, the Pope and the Church would be subjected greatly to the affairs of the City of Man. Imagine the persecution the Church would have faced if they didn't have the Leonine city to defend themselves from the Revolutionary French, Nationalist Italians, and Nazi Germany.

Historically, there has never been much Italian unity, after the congress of Vianna in 1815 Italy was divided into 10 different territories. In Southern Italy was the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies (its last ruler and his mother are both on the path to sainthood, Servant of God Francis II and Blessed Maria of Savoy). In Central Italy the Papal States (the last “Pope-King” is also on the path to sainthood, Blessed Pope Pius IX) and San Marino. In Northern Italy was the Kingdom of Sardinia-Piedmont and Monaco, along with Austrian controlled Kingdom of Lombardy and Venetia and the Austrian influenced Duchies of Parma, Tuscany, and Modena.

On the heels of the enlightenment the 19th century saw the rise of liberalism, rationalism, and nationalism. Revolutionaries across the peninsula got caught up in nationalistic fervor. With the help of secret societies, individuals such as Cavour, Garibaldi, Mazzini, and those in the Piedmontese monarchy, despite conflicting desires for particular styles of government wanted nothing more than a united Italy, even if it was achieved through violence, conniving, and treachery. The Church and the Pope were about to suffer greatly.

Blessed Pope Pius IX enthroned
Blessed Pope Pius IX enthroned

The Early Years of Bl. Pope Pius IX

In order to understand the conflict better we have to examine the Papacy of Bl. Pope Pius IX. Elected in 1846 as a candidate put forth by the liberal camp, as he had gained a reputation for liberalism due to how he handled revolutionaries in Spoleto and since he had supported administrative reforms while in Imola. The beginning of Bl. Pope Pius IX's pontificate was characterized by his openness to comprise with ideologies that were hostile to the faith in an effort to control their influence and spread. He was by no means a liberal but was seen as someone who they could control and influence. For example, after much pressure, one of his first acts was to grant an amnesty on July 16, 1846 to various political prisoners and exiles in the Papal States. Revolutionaries used this act to push a narrative that Bl. Pius IX was a supporter of liberal causes. Despite his first encyclical, Qui Pluribus published on November 9, 1846, denouncing liberalism, freemasonry, and communism in an effort to show he wasn't a liberal himself, the revolutionaries continued to pray on his willingness to compromise. Such as coaxing him to create a civil constitution, civic guard, and a lay run government.

The revolutionary year of 1848 proved to be an especially difficult year for Bl. Pius IX. There were plans to make an Italian Federation with the Pope as the permanent head and President. However, Piedmont was unwilling to see Italy united in anyway other then under their thumb. They went to war with Austrian and the Kingdom of Lombardy-Venetia, forcing Bl. Pius IX to abandon the plans of federation as he wanted no part in waring with a son of the Church. After Piedmont was defeated, they again considered a federated Italy but Piedmont again appeared unwilling. The situation become much worse after Pius IX's minister Pellegrino Rossi was murdered while attending the Papal States parliament on November 15. This incited a revolution in Rome, forcing Bl. Pius IX to flee to Gaeta in the Two Sicilies. An expeditionary force was created by the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies, Spain, and France to destroy the Roman Republic, they were successful after fighting in 1849 and Bl. Pius IX. was restored on April 12, 1850. The ordeal made him do an about-face in his dealings with modern ideologies. Instead he became a staunch counter-revolutionary and ultramontane.

Cavalry engagement during the 1859 war for Italian unification
Sardinia-Piedmontese King Victor Emmanuel II

The Start of the Conflict

The decade following Sardinia-Piedmont continued its plotting to takeover the Peninsula. Everything came to a head in 1859. The King of Sardinia-Piedmont, Victor Emmanuel II, and his Prime Minister Cavour started the next stage in their campaign to unite Italy. A secret agreement was signed between Cavour and French Emperor Napoleon III early in the year, and the Emperor promised to help push the Austrians out of the peninsula in return for Savoy and Nice near the French border. In March, the Piedmontese began mobilizing along the border with Lombardy, provoking Austria to mobilize themselves. In April, when the Kingdom of Sardinia refused to de-mobilize, Austria invaded. France quickly joined Piedmont, and together after several months Austria was defeated.

During this time, Sardinia staged uprisings in Tuscany, Parma, Modena, and the northernmost territory of the Papal States, the Romagna, causing them to destabilize. Shortly after the war ended, these territories were annexed by Sardinia-Piedmont after faux plebiscites. With Austria defeated, they ceded Lombardy to France, who gave it to Sardinia, and in turn Sardinia ceded Savoy and Nice to France. Napoleon III tried his best to influence Bl. Pius IX to accept the annexation of the Romagna to Sardinia-Piedmont. However, the Holy Father held his ground and excommunicated all of those who had taken part in its capture. Now was the time to resist.

The Papal Army Reborn · 1860
Monsignor Xavier de Mérode, Papal Minister of Arms
Monsignor Xavier de Mérode, Papal Minister of Arms

Strengthening the Papal Army

There were two options in front of Bl. Pius IX. The Cardinal Secretary of State Giacomo Antonelli wanted to rely on diplomacy, while Monsignor Xavier de Mérode, a private chamberlain of the Pope, believed that diplomacy could not be relied upon, as it was not enough to curb the nationalistic fervor of King Victor Emmanuel II and the Italian revolutionaries. He believed the only way to defend the temporal power was by force, and strengthening the Papal Army would be necessary to protect the Papal States.

This would be a huge undertaking as the Papal Army was very weak and ill-equipped. However, Mérode had a vision that the Army could be revitalized through a multinational force of pious Catholics from around the world, akin to a Crusade. Bl. Pius IX was convinced, he approved of Mérode's plan, and promoted him to Papal Minister of Arms. The volunteers of the Pope would go on to view themselves as soldiers fighting in the 9th Crusade.

Soldiers of the multinational Papal Army of 1860
Soldiers of the multinational Papal Army of 1860

The Makeup of the Papal Army of 1860

The plan was put into effect immediately, with more than 5,000 foreign recruits raised from almost 30 different countries. Most were Irish, Austrian, French, and Dutch. The Austrians formed five battalions of light infantry; the Irish formed the Battalion of St. Patrick; and the French and Dutch formed the Franco-Belgian Battalion. Here is the beginning of the Papal Zouaves; after the 1860 campaign, the Franco-Belgians transitioned into the Papal Zouaves.

Many of these volunteers came from noble lineage. Additionally, many had ancestors or relatives who had fought in other Counter-Revolutionary efforts, such as the war in the Vendée. In fact, the first group of foreign volunteers was the Crusaders of Cathelineau, led by Henri de Cathelineau, the grandson of Vendéen General Jacques Cathelineau. The group existed only a few months before being incorporated into the Franco-Belgian Battalion.

General Christophe de Lamoricière, commander of the Papal Army
General Christophe de Lamoricière, commander of the Papal Army in 1860

The Commander of the Papal Army: La Moricière

Former French General de la Moricière was selected to lead the Papal Army. Motivated by his Catholic faith, he understood how important the coming conflict would be. In an address given to new volunteers on Easter Sunday 1860, he said:

At the sound of the grand voice which lately apprised the world from the Vatican of the dangers threatening the patrimony of St. Peter, Catholics were moved, and their emotion soon spread to every part of the earth. This is because Christianity is not merely the religion of the civilized world, but the animating principle of civilization; it is because the Papacy is the keystone of the arch of Christianity, and all Christian nations seem, in these days, to be conscious of those great varieties which are our faith. The revolution today threatens Europe as Islamism did of old, and now, as then, the cause of the Pope is that of civilization and liberty throughout the world. Soldiers, have confidence, and believe that God will raise our courage to the level of the great cause whose defense He has entrusted to our arms.

La Moricière was also important because he wanted a unit of Zouaves in his army. Having firsthand experience with the effectiveness of this type of light infantry, he had led a regiment of Zouaves in Algeria in 1838. The origins of the Zouaves can be traced back to 1831, after the French conquest of Algeria. The French made allies with the Kabyles, a Berber people living in the mountains. One of their tribes, the Zwawa, were known as fierce warriors and wanted to fight under their new rulers. Battalions of these native Zwawa were formed under the name Zouave. Shortly thereafter, companies of French Zouaves began to form. This type of elite light infantry unit became extremely popular in the 19th century, with units being raised in the Union, the Confederacy, Poland, Spain, and, of course, the Papal States. At the time, the Franco-Belgian battalion was a Zouave unit in all but name, and it wasn't long before their commander, Major Becdelievre, pushed for the adoption of the Zouave uniform.

Engraving of the fighting during the 1860 campaign
Engraving of the Battle of Castelfidardo, September 18, 1860

The 1860 Campaign

Seeking to continue uniting the Peninsula, Cavour secretly coordinated with Garibaldi for his Red Shirts to seize the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies. By May, Garibaldi's forces had landed in Sicily, and he declared himself dictator in the name of Victor Emmanuel II. By September, the entire Kingdom was under his control, with the exception of over ten thousand holdouts in Capua, Civitella del Tronto, and Gaeta, commanded by Francis II. All eyes were now on the Papal States.

A French garrison was stationed in Rome to help guarantee the Pope's temporal power. However, Cavour had received Napoleon III's blessing to take all of the Papal States, with the exception of the Lazio region (Rome and its surrounding territory), without French interference. With this act, Napoleon III turned his back on his Catholic subjects.

In early September, Sardinia and secret societies began inciting civil unrest in the northern territories of the Papal States. Under the guise of restoring order, Sardinia invaded the Papal States with 70,000 soldiers on September 11, 1860. The Papal States' only hope for victory was if Austria sent reinforcements to bolster the Papal Army through the port of Ancona in the northeast of the Papal States. In anticipation of these supposed reinforcements, the Papal plan was to have the majority of the army maneuver to the city and defend it from siege.

Unfortunately, the majority of the army was routed during the Battle of Castelfidardo on September 18, 1860. The loss was so catastrophic that it became known as a massacre, and the fallen Papal soldiers were seen as martyrs. The battlefield was filled with so many noble Catholic youths from France that an Italian general commented, “You would think this was a list of invites for a ball given by Louis XIV!” One soldier who gave their life was Joseph Louis Guerin, the Papal Zouave who has come closest to Sainthood.

Painting depicting the death of Papal Zouave Joseph Louis Guérin
Painting depicting the death of Papal Zouave Joseph Louis Guérin

Joseph Louis Guérin

Guérin was born in 1838 in Nantes, France. In 1860, he was in seminary and about to become a sub-deacon when he answered the call of General Lamoricie to come to the aid of the holy father, when one of his friends asked why he was joining he said “Blood is necessary to appease the anger of God; I will give mine” when he broke the news to his parents, they wept, but enthusiastically supported his decision. His Father said “I have already lost a son; but if God asks me for another I will give him!” On his journey to Rome Guérin read through the Imitation of Christ and frequently recited the office of Our Lady. He arrived on August 8th, 1860. And joined the unit the Knights of St. Peter. Shortly after Guérin's arrival the Knights were incorporated into the Franco-Belgium Battalion. Guerin was put into the 4th company.

All new recruits had to go through two sets of school's the Soldiers School and the Battalion School. The first school typically takes a month but Guérin passed in only 8 days. This helped him gain the respect of his comrades and leaders. Guérin was a model soldier, he regularly volunteered for arduous and time-consuming tasks that typically were assigned at random such as fetching water for a squad, often doing so before the command was even issued. His comrade Padioleau said of him “If we asked a man of goodwill for a chore, we always saw him first, forgetting his ease and his rest and leaving the tent if he was in bed” Guérin would endure all the annoyances of everyday life without ever complaining. Confident, he relied entirely on God and wanted to be kind to everyone. He was eager to “exercise his zeal for the salvation of souls” whenever he could. He inspired his comrades to be more faithful and zealous, encouraging his comrades who waivered he would say “Why are you afraid? If your conscience is not in peace, there is the chaplain. Our cause is the better; we fight for God, therefore we are men of eternity; what signify the few days that we will sacrifice? I have made the sacrifice of my life to the Church and Pius IX. I am not afraid to die!”

Guerin's company was assigned to one of the columns that fought at Castelfidardo, his company arrived at Loreto which was where the Holy House was, the famed home of the Holy Family, the night before the battle on Sep. 17, 1860. Tired and hungry, the Papal soldiers had endured a difficult week of marches through the mountains to reach Loreto. Through the Franco-Belgium Battalion were still eager to fight. Guérin “Passing in front of Loretto, he could not take his eyes off the dome which covers the Santa Casa” Loreto was only about 20 miles from Ancona. However, the Piedmontese were stationed in Castelfidardo, a town immediately adjacent to Loreto and on the way to Ancona, they were planning on cutting off the Papal forces from Ancona.

The next morning, Pontifical Army set out and engaged the Piedmontese in the mountains and hills of Castelfidardo in an effort to allow a portion of their force to continue on to Ancona. Guerin's Franco-Belgian company was with General Pimodan's column during the battle. During one of the pontifical bayonet charges uphill to seize a farmhouse Guérin fell. According to Pvt. Oscar de Poli Guérin took a ball to the lung. While Poli was on the ground after suffering a bayonet wound Guérin charged passed him saying “Poli, farewell Poli! Do not forget to say: Jesus, Mary; goodbye!” Fifty paces later, Poli saw Guérin fall. Later on, Cpl. Perrodil found him on battlefield lifeless “There he was, lying on his back. I bent down to touch him he was cold and stiff. I then knelt to impress on his pure brow a kiss of regret and love in the name of his parents. I took his scarf, and bade him a last farewell believing him dead. He had been very brave, poor child, and had fallen a few steps from the enemy.” Eventually Guérin regained conscience on an ambulance headed toward a temporary infirmary set up in a Castelfidardo convent. He turned to a young Italian near him and said in Latin “Tell the Priest of my hometown that I die joyfully and calmly for the cause of religion and the Pope; let him console my parents with the hope of meeting me one day in heaven” The Superior of the convent pointed out to him a prophetic coincidence that pleased Guérin: “Your name is Joseph, you fought yesterday, on the feast day of Saint Joseph of Copertino, you were laid down in front of an altar dedicated to him; tomorrow you will be transported to Osimo, where the same saint died; perhaps you will be placed in our church, where the body of Saint Joseph is kept” The next day he was brought to a Piedmontese hospital in Osimo. He suffered intensely for 7 weeks. But did not complain, instead he gave words of thanksgiving and joy. He wrote to a friend “I have made to God and to the Holy Church the sacrifice of my life. Envy my happiness and console my poor mother. Long live Pius IX! Long live the Pope King!” He repeated often “How happy I am to suffer and die slowly for Jesus Christ and his Church” In his final letter to his parents, he wrote “It is Gods will (that I die); let us bless and adore it” On Oct. 30th he felt the end was near. He received last rites and said his final words “My God, I beg of you to forgive those who have wounded me. My God accept my sufferings! Do not weep or fret my kind friends, I am going to God” He died with a smile. Almost Immediately an intense and popular piety developed around him. Over 30 miraculous healings occurred over a decade. Bl. Pope Pius IX placed a portrait of Guérin in the antechamber of his private chapel in Castel-Gandolfo. Guérin even appeared to others in visions.

Even after his death, Guérin was spoken very highly of in the Papal Zouaves. He was a constant source of intercession for them and was mentioned frequently in their writings and stories. Upon an invitation from Bl. Pius IX, the Bishop of Nantes began the canonization process in 1862. Why then is Guérin not canonized? Unfortunately, it appears he became a victim of the political climate of the time. Due to the precarious situation with the Papal States some felt it was not appropriate to potentially anger Napolean III by canonizing a Papal soldier that embodied the values of royalism and monarchism. In 1925 his caused was reconsidered but the political climate prevented the process from moving forward again this is due to the French monarchist group, Action Française being condemned by Pope Pius XI. Considering how it's been almost 100 years since Guérin's cause has been last considered his cause ought to be looked into again.

Portrait of Papal Zouave Commander Athanase de Charrette
Portrait of Papal Zouave Commander Athanase de Charrette (1860-1861)

Other Heroes of Castelfidardo

Other heroes of the battle of Castelfidardo include Captain Athanse de Charette, who bested one of his former classmates of the military academy of Turin in a chivalric saber duel during the battle. troops. Charette upon encountering Tromboni exclaimed “En garde!” and called to his troops to stand fast. Soldiers from both sides briefly lowered their weapons and stopped fighting to witness a chivalric Sabre duel between former classmates. Tromboni was bested and fell bleeding profusely. Charette declared “This man is my prisoner. Take him to an ambulance and care for him.” He then turned to his company and in a loud and commanding voice bid his soldiers to advance “En avant, les efants!”, and the battle then resumed. Another hero was General Pimodan who became mortally wounded during the battle while leading his troops from the front. While attempting to rally his men to charge uphill, General Pimodan was shot three times. In the jaw, then foot, and finally his chest. Each time he was struck he shouted “Courage, my children, God is with us!” he fell off his horse and was taken to an aid station.

the papal zouaves take shape · 1861–1866
Map of the Papal States after the territorial losses of 1860
Map of the Papal States after the territorial losses of 1860

Aftermath of 1860

The campaign of 1860 ended in defeat. After Castelfidardo, the Piedmontese laid siege to Ancona which fell on September 29. The defeat resulted in Victor Emmanul II annexing the captured Papal territories and proclaiming the Kingdom of Italy. The Pope's temporal power was reduced to only the Lazio region which was Rome and its immediate surroundings. Bl. Pius IX protested these losses, but the majority of the world ignored him. While the fighting stopped momentarily, the threat against the Papal States persisted. The revolutionaries would not rest until all of Italy was united.

Over the next few years, the Papal Army grew stronger and became more well-trained. The Franco-Belgian Battalion officially transitioned to the Papal Zouaves on January 1, 1861. The term “Franco-Belgian” and “Papal Zouave” were often used interchangeably as the Papal Zouaves viewed the Franco-Belgians as part of their pedigree and considered them part of their unit. Over 10,000 men would join the Papal Zouaves over the course of its lifetime. The largest the unit ever grew was in 1868, reaching the size of a full regiment with four battalions, totaling almost 5,000 men. However, they started off as a 600-man battalion with six companies.

Unfortunately, due to a disagreement between Mérode and Becdelievre, the latter resigned command of the unit in March. Most of the soldiers wanted Athanase de Charette, the great-nephew of Vendéen General François de Charette, to lead the unit. However, since he was a legitimist, Bl. Pius IX did not want to anger Napoleon III and risk losing the French garrison stationed in Rome. Instead, Swiss Colonel Allet, who had been in the Papal Army for many years, was chosen to lead the unit, and Charette was promoted to Major. Charette's time would come, however, as he eventually led a contingent of French Papal Zouaves during the Franco-Prussian War. The men loved both men, Allet was effectionally called “Papa Allet”

Papal Zouaves photographed during garrison life
Oil portrait of the Villèle Papal Zouave brothers. From left to right: Corporal Gaston de Villèle, Lieutenant Louis de Villèle, Sergeant Charles de Villèle.

1861 – 1866

Over the next few years, the Papal Zouaves mostly lived a garrison life. The main threats the Papal States faced were brigands and other criminals along the borders and in the mountains, with occasional border disputes with the Piedmontese. Aside from military duties, the Papal Zouaves were often involved in religious ceremonies, including processions, masses on feast days, and whenever Bl. Pius IX spoke from his balcony. The unit was defined by its piety and devotion to the faith. To become a Papal Zouave, a recruit needed a letter of recommendation from a priest. All recruits, regardless of social class, began as privates, even among the nobility, such as Prince Alfonso Carlos de Bourbon, the future rightful King of Spain. Pay and rations were meager—half a penny a day, soup, bread, and coffee. Despite the low pay, many Zouaves were generous with their tithes, and most of their free time was spent in churches praying or participating in various Catholic confraternities.

However, the monotony of garrison life did not suit everyone. After an initial boost in numbers following the loss in 1860, recruitment began to decline. This trend was seen in other units as well. For example, the Battalion of St. Patrick was reduced to the Company of St. Patrick and ultimately was dissolved, with the remainder of the soldiers being incorporated into the Papal Zouaves in 1862 By 1863 the number of Papal Zouaves dropped to 300. However, this would soon change.

It started with another backstab from Napoleon III. On September 15, 1864 France signed an agreement with Italy known as the September Convention. It was agreed that Napoleon III would evacuate the French garrison in Rome over the next two years. Additionally, Italy, among other things, promised not to attack the Pope's territory. However, this agreement was merely for show, as it opened the door for Garibaldi and his Red Shirts to invade and cede Rome to Italy without French interference just as they did with the Kingdom of Two Sicilies in 1860. If they failed, Victor Emmanuel II could pretend that they had nothing to do with Garibaldi.

When the agreement was made public in early 1865, there was outrage in Rome at the betrayal of Napoleon III, as it foreshadowed events to come. Upon hearing the news, General de la Moricière, who had been living in France since the defeat of the Papal Army in 1860, prepared to return to lead the army. However, he died and General Herman Kanzler was made Commander of the Papal Army; in 1860 Monsignor Merode resigned as pro-minister of arms, and Kanzler also assumed that position.

There was a surge of Papal Zouave recruits as the threat to the Papal States grew significantly. The unit grew to 1500 men, two more line companies and a depot company were added. Activity with revolutionaries and brigands also increased during this time as they attempted to capitalize off the French exit.

Recruitment swelled again in 1866 after Piedmont passed a series of anti-clerical laws which included imprisonment of bishops, banning of Papal encyclicals, forbidding religious processions, closing of seminaries, subjecting priests to conscription, among many more heinous and anti-catholic acts.

Meanwhile, in the summer of 1866, Victor Emmaneul II joined forces with Prussia against the Austrians in the Seven Weeks' War. The goal of the Kingdom of Italy was to remove the last vestige of Austrian influence on the peninsula. While Italy did not fare so well during the war, Prussia was victorious and the Austrian controlled Kingdom of Venetia was ceded to France who then ceded the territory to Italy, just like what happened with Nice and Savoy in 1860.

Crisis and Victory · 1867
Papal Zouaves assisting during the 1867 cholera outbreak at Albano
Papal Zouaves assisting during the 1867 cholera outbreak at Albano

The Outbreak at Albano

By December 1866 the French Garrison had left Rome. All that remained between Victor Emmanuel II and a united Italy was Bl. Pius IX and the last remaining territory of the Papal States. By January 1867, the Papal Zouaves had swelled to a regiment with 4 battalions. Confident in God and His soldiers, Bl. Pius IX announced the convening of the first Vatican Council in October 1869. While the enemies of the Church were plotting to attack the Papal States, a terrible cholera outbreak erupted in the region, hitting the town of Albano just outside of Rome particularly hard. The civil government in the town collapsed, the mayor and most of the residents fled leaving piles of bodies in the street and the sick to fend for themselves. The only figures that stayed and helped the Sisters of Charity in their care for the sick was the archbishop, Cardinal Altieri, and the vacationing and exiled royal family of the Two Sicilies. The disease would claim the archbishop and the queen mother.

Help arrived in the form of the 6th company of the 2nd battalion of Papal Zouaves. The Lieutenant in charge of the first detachment of Zouaves that arrived was the first to pick up a corpse and carry it to the cemetery. He called out to his men: “I set the example; those who want to work with me stay here, those who don't feel up to it go back to the barracks.” The Papal Zouaves followed his example at their own peril. By August 20 the epidemic had subsided but not before claiming two Dutchmen in the unit. One of them, Henri Peters, found consolation in his final moments by holding a crucifix. With his dying lips he kissed it fervently, and exclaimed, “I know that Heaven is before me when all this is past.”

Papal Zouave carrying the pontifical flag, 1867 campaign
Anti-Catholic Italian Revolutionary Leader Giuseppe Garibaldi

The 1867 Campaign

With the summer epidemic over, the French garrison no longer in Rome, and Lombardy under Italian control, Victor Emmanul II initiated his plans to capture Rome. The prime minister at the time, Rattazzi and his cabinet, supplied Garibaldi with arms, supplies, and money and allowed him to raise an army. In late September, Garibaldi and his two sons began their invasion of the Lazio region. Their goal was to cause civil unrest and seize Rome, and they hoped that their invasion would cause revolutionaries to rise up and assist them in their takeover, much like what happened in 1849. If Garibaldi failed to take Rome the plan was to have the Kingdom of Italy declare that due to the civil unrest, they needed to send their Army to “restore order.”

The Red Shirts numbered well over 10,000 while the Papal Army numbered around 13,000, but had an effective fighting force only around 8,000 with over 2,000 Papal Zouaves. Over the next month the Papal Army fought bravely and fended off most attacks that came from the Garibaldians. In late October, the Red Shirts attempted to incite a revolution in Rome, but it failed to gain any traction. On October 22 about 500 Red Shirts infiltrated the city and bombed over a dozen places. One of them was a Papal Zouave barracks at the Palazzo Serritorsi. The explosion destroyed the building and killed 25 Zouaves, most of them from the band and four civilians, including a little girl. The attacks that night from the Red Shirts were repelled by the Papal Zouaves. More attacks occurred the following day, but they too failed. The city clearly was not going to fall to the revolutionary force.

During this time, Empress Eugenie and pressure from French Catholics convinced Napoleon III to denounce the invasion of the Pope's territory and to send him a sizable force to help defeat the Red Shirts. Garibaldi attempted to seize Rome before the French force arrived, but he was unable to do so.

Painting of the Battle of Mentana, by Lionel Royer
Painting of the Battle of Mentana, by Lionel Royer

The Battle of Mentana

On October 30, the French force arrived in Rome. Garibaldi, hoping to draw France into a conflict with the Kingdom of Italy, pulled his forces back in an attempt to link up with the Italian Royal Army. Realizing his plan, the commander of the Papal Army General Kanzler, with French reinforcements, pursued the Red Shirts and routed them in the town of Mentana on November 3, 1867. The Papal Zouaves were the tip of the spear during the battle, and it was through their efforts that the battle was won. By nightfall, the Papal Army had Garibaldi's Army trapped and surrounded inside the town. The next morning the Red Shirts surrendered, and the Papal and French forces occupied the town. Unfortunately, Garibaldi escaped capture. He had slipped away during the battle with half his force into the safety of Italian territory. Not wanting to start a war they were unprepared for, the Royal Army did not assist the Red Shirts. Garibaldi himself would never again invade the Papal States. The victory at Mentana is considered the greatest battle ever won by the Papal Zouaves. A monument was dedicated to their victory and to the fallen at the Campo Verano cemetery in Rome which included the names of all of the martyrs who fell during the campaign.

Painting depicting close combat during the 1867 campaign
Engraving depicting the Martyrdom of Emmanuel Dufournel

The Martyrdom of the Dufournel Brothers

Two of those names were Papal Zouave officers and brothers Adeodat and Emmanuel Dufournel. Adeodat had fought at Castelfidardo in 1860. Inspired by his brother's heroism, Emmanuel joined him at the end of 1860. By 1867 Adeodat was a Captain and Emmanuel a Lieutenant. During the 1867 invasion, Emmanuels company had been patrolling the border near Valetano. They received word that around 60 Garibaldians were around the town of Farnese and they made preparations to expel the band of revolutionaries. The night prior to the assault, Emmanul made a confession. On the morning of October 20th, after attending mass and receiving communion, his contingent set off, he led a platoon of 20 Zouaves alongside Captain Sparacanna of the line infantry commanding 30 men. As the men got closer to Farnese, intelligence reported that there were actually 300 Garibaldians instead of 60. Emmanuel insisted on moving forward despite the discrepancy in manpower. About a kilometer from Farnese, the Garibaldians launched a surprise attack against the pontificals from a nearby house. Emmanuel responded by slowly drawing his uniform's gloves from his pocket and carefully putting them on, he adjusted his kepi, and, drawing his sword from its scabbard, and making the sign of the cross with the blade, he saluted his Zouaves and said: 'Here, my children, is where we must die! In nomine Patris et Filii et Spiritus Sancti, Forward!'

The Garibaldians were driven back from the house, as the Zouaves occupied it. As they rested for a moment to plan their next move they noticed a column of 200 Garibaldians burling toward them. They barricaded the house as best they could to stand their ground. 40 bold Garibaldians rushed forward and surrounded the house. Emmanul ordered “Lets drive them out with bayonets!” as he pushed back the makeshift barricade at the door and rushed toward the enemy. Saber in hand, he struck a Garibaldian on the head so vigorously that his blade broke in two and slipped from his hand; a dozen of these wretches threw themselves on him and he was struck fourteen times with their bayonets. Immediately his comrades in came out of the house and charged at the Garibaldians causing them to retreat. They recovered Emmanuel, brought him back to the house, and laid him on a mattress. “All my wounds are in front...tell my brother he can be proud of me” he said happily, which proved that he faced the enemy head on instead of retreating. Emmanuel encouraged his men to fight on. Despite the overwhelming odds, the teneacity Emmanul had shown led the Zouaves to victory, they Garibaldians had retreated leaving Farnese in their hands. Reinforcements arrived a few hours later and Emmanul was carried on a stretcher 7 miles to Valentano, the weather was terrible as it was pouring rain and the jolts Emmanuel felt from the terrain agonized him, but he did not complain. They arrived in Valentano 3 hours later during the night, a doctor patched him up but believed he would not make it to the morning. He was given last rights, when the Viaticum came he insisted on standing but his friends held him back. The priest told him to 'Make your sacrifice in union with that of Our Lord JESUS CHRIST,' Emmanul responded 'My sacrifice is made, I die for our religion, I am content.' Shortley before dying he began to tremble, one of our comrades was whispering the names of Jesus, Mary, Joseph, close to his ear. There was one more back-and-forth movement in the arm, then the arm fell lifeless. He gave up his soul at six in the morning after suffering happily, his only regrets were not being able to see his brother and continue fighting. Adeodat would follow him in martyrdom 10 days later.

Portrait of a Papal Zouave officer
Dutch Papal Zouave Pieter Jong, clubbing 14 Red Shirts to death before being killed at the battle of Monte Libretti.

Other Heroes of the 1867 Campaign

Other hero's of the 1867 campaign include the dutchman Pieter Jong who clubbed 14 Red Shirts to death before he was martyred at the battle of Monte Libretti, on October 13th, 1867. Allowing his lone company to rescue the town from 1200 Garibaldians. And Jullian Watts-Russell, an Englishman who joined the Zouaves alongside his brother. He was the first to reach the castle walls at Mentana and the youngest to die on the field that day at only 17. He was often compared to Guerin in piety and his phrase “Anima mia, anima mia, Ama Dio e tira via” My Soul, My Soul, Love thy God and go thy way.

The victory at Mentana bought the Papal States three more years. Which in turn allowed the First Vatican Council to happen starting on December 8, 1869. Without the heroism of the Papal Zouaves, would the dogma of papal infallibility and other fruits of the Council have been promulgated? The victory at Mentana led to another surge in recruitment, Dutchman would overtake as the majority nationality and for the first time large contingents of English and Canadians joined. The unit reaching its highest numbers in 1868, almost 5,000 soldiers. Over the next three years things were relatively quiet.

M1868 Remington Rolling Block rifle, the Pontifico
M1868 Remington Rolling Block rifles, the Pontifico

The M1868 Remington Rolling Block Rifle

During this interregnum period. the Papal Army received an upgrade in its standard rifle. By 1869, all of the Papal Zouaves were equipped with their new breach-loading rifle, the M1868 Remington Rolling Block, also known as the Pontifico. In the 1860s, leading up to the adoption of the Rolling Block rifle, Papal troops were armed with a diverse mix of French, Austrian, and locally produced Papal firearms—many of which were clones of Italian and French designs. With the standard rifles being a percussion-cap version of the French M1822 muzzleloader and the Mazzochi M1857 carbine. However, when General Kanzler was appointed as the Minster of War and commander of the Papal Forces in 1865, he sought to standardize the army's equipment and arm it with the most advanced weaponry available.

In August 1866, the Papal government solicited 2,000 Chassepot rifles from the Belgian “Committee for the Defense of the Holy See,” a Belgian organization dedicated to supporting the Pontifical military during this time. After a contract was placed with Emile and Leon Nagant in 1867, Kanzler opted to cancel it and instead order 5,000 Remington Rolling Block rifles, which were seen as the cutting-edge technology of the time. With the cost of still being subsidized by the Belgian Committee. After the arrival of the French during the 1867 campaign, some Papal Zouaves were equipped with Chassepot rifles by the French. This was the first time in history that this type of rifle was being fielded in combat and it proved to be a huge success. A French committee ordered another batch of 5,000 Remington rifles for Kanzler with Westley Richards of Birmingham, England. Unfortunately, these Westley Richards rifles, delivered in early 1868, were so poorly finished that they were deemed unserviceable. Gunsmiths from Liège had to be brought in to repair and improve them, which caused a delay in issuing them to troops. Later in 1868, the 5,000 Nagant-manufactured Remington rifles arrived in Rome, followed by an additional 1,600 by the end of the year.

The Fall of Rome · 1870
Portrait of Charles Tracey, future American Congressman and Papal Zouave
Portrait of Charles Tracey, American Congressman and Papal Zouave

The 1870 Invasion

The three years of quiet was broke by the start of the Franco-Prussian War in the summer of 1870. After the Battle of Mentana, Napoleon III kept a garrison of 4,000 soldiers in Cività Vecchia. However, his war with Prussia was not going well, and he was getting desperate. He recalled the force in Rome and declared he was returning to the rules of the September convention. On September 2, Napoleon III was captured after his defeat at the Battle of Sedan. With France out of the way and Austria too weak to assist the Papal States, Victor Emmanuel II pounced on the opportunity. Afraid of having Garibaldi invade and risk destabilizing his monarchy, Victor Emmanuel II decided to use his Royal Army to invade Rome.

When word got out that the Italians were threatening Rome again, many former Papal Zouaves rushed back to Rome to come to the defense of the Holy Father. Included in those was future American Congressman Charles Tracey from New York. A second generation Irish American, Charles had grown up in Albany in a pius and influential family. When the news of the victory of Mentana broke Charles felt compelled to render his aid to the Holy Father. The 20 year old Charles joined the Zouaves at the end of 1867 and served with them periodically through the fall of 1869. He returned to New York and joined his father and brother in leading the family distillery business.

Keeping up to date with the events through the newspapers, Charles realized how dire the situation was and left for Rome in late August to rejoin his comrades. He went “as fast as rail and sail” could take him. While he was on his way Victor Emmanul II began his invasion. On September 9, the Royal Army posed themselves on the Lazio's border. Victor Emmanuel II wrote Bl. Pope Pius IX a letter and sent Count Gustavo Ponza di San Martino to deliver it the following day on September 10. The letter, which really was just a guise to request a bloodless takeover, claimed that due to the removal of French troops from the city, it was necessary for his forces to occupy the Eternal City so that they could maintain law and order from Roman revolutionaries. A strange thing to say since there were no revolutionary uprisings in Rome at the time. Bl. Pius IX did not appreciate the hypocrisy in the letter. He replied to Count Ponza. “What a race of vipers! Whited sepulchers! and wanting in faith!” Count Ponza became so afraid that he rushed out of the room and mistook a window for a door, almost falling to his death. Bl. Pius IX refused to be bullied. He rejected Victor Emmanuel II's offer, an action which certainly would lead to war, one which would be very difficult. The Italian Army had over 75,000 troops stationed on the frontier ready for action, meanwhile the Papal Army had only around 12,000 men.

After Count Ponza left, General Kanzler alongside his chief of staff, Major Rivolta, went to see Bl. Pius IX. to discuss the plans for defense. When he finished his brief, Bl. Pius IX. said “I am going to have to disappoint the army. It will have to surrender.” General Kanzler was shocked, Bl. Pius IX. explained that he did not want to lead Rome into death and destruction and leave that behind as his legacy. He wanted the army, upon invasion, to fall back onto Rome. However, bits of resistance were allowed on the way to show the world that the temporal power was being taken by force. General Kanzler, was upset at the decision, he protested and tried to persuade the Pope to allow his men to fight and die, he told him “the entire army from the highest officer to the most humble soldier wants to fight and die.” Bl. Pius IX. remained firm in his decision and responded “We choose to surrender, not to die is sometimes the bigger sacrifice.”

The Italians began their invasion on September 11. The Papal Army put up some resistance but started to fall back to Rome on the Pope's orders, the one exception being Cività Vecchia, the Papal port just north of Rome, so that the Pope could have a potential route to escape if needed. Meanwhile, Charles was still enroute to the Holy City, the fastest way was through Cività Vecchia. Instead of taking a French steamer to the city which was typical, he elected to through Germany by train. Due to their war with France, the German military was regularly seizing passenger trains. This caused his baggage to be delayed, rather than suffer a delay himself, Charles abandoned his things and proceeded to Cività Vecchia. However, when Charles arrived on September 16, he found that the port city had just surrendered

Bl. Pius IX had updated his surrender orders. The Holy City needed to be surrendered “at the first cannon shots.” And Cività Vecchia given up immediately. The Papal forces had just left when Charles arrived and the Italian General Bixio occupied the city. Charles was unsure of what do to, he spent the night at the Hotel Orlando. The following day while outside on the steps of the hotel he saw his friend Patrick Keye's O'Clery were re-united with him. O'Clery, a former Irish Zouave had served together with Charles in 1868. He had also arrived on the 16th and had found another fellow who wanted to join the Papal Zouaves, Englishman John George Kenyon. The trio found one more gentleman to join their crew, Charles Hemans, a now Roman resident of many years, writer, and correspondent for various London papers.

O'Clery revealed to Charles he was tasked with a special mission. On his journey back to Rome O'Clery had stopped in the papal consul in Marseilles. There he was given important letters and dispatches by the Consul General for the Cardinal Secretary of State and various papal military leaders, to smuggle back to Rome. The Italians had cut off all communication from the city so these documents were vital. O'Clery and Kenyon had heard that Bixio was supposed to set out dawn the following day to Rome, they believed this large movement of troops would cause enough confusion where they would be able make a break for the open country and make it to Rome before the Italian forces arrived.

The group decided to spend the night at the Orlando and find a carriage to take them to Rome in the early hours the following morning. That night, after everyone in the hotel had gone to sleep, Tracey and O'Clery stayed up went through the papers O'Clery had received. They figured the packet of papers was too bulky and they needed to reduce its size so that they could conceal it easier if they ran into Italian authorities. They burned any papers they deemed unnecessary, and took the remaining papers and letters and bundled them up in a smaller packet and put it away in a satchel.

The following morning, Bixio set off with his 20,000 men, the group found a driver who as only willing to take them as far as Palo which was about 25 miles away, they agreed and off they went. Through it was slow going and they were stopped frequently, they made it to Palo. There they came across the Italian army and, wondering what two Englishmen, an Irishman, and American were doing so close to their maneuvers, were placed under arrest. The group was brought before General Bixio himself.

General Bixio angrily turned toward the group and demanded that they hand over their passports and tell them where they intended on going. They answered truthfully that they intended on going to Rome. However, they concealed the fact that they were going so they could defend the city from his army. Instead, they claimed they were newspaper men, which was another half-truth since Hermans was one. He informed that they were not allowed to go until the city was taken by his forces and their rule was established. O'Clery described the situation further:

[General Bixio] muttered something about sending us back to Cività Vecchia, and then suddenly apologizing for his rudeness of manner, he invited us to join his mess. And enter Rome with his troops. As Pontifical Zouaves we could not allow ourselves to be under a compliment to one of Garibaldi's lieutenants, so we declined his offer with thanks, preferring to take up our quarters for the night in the deserted albergo (inn) at Palo, in front of which Piedmontese gendarmes were subsequently posted, doubles to take care of us.

The situation was not ideal, Kenyon said that “We had to sleep all together in a little dirty room, the whole place being full of Piedmontese.” Charles said of their predicament “This did not suit us at all. We were eager to join the zouaves in order to take part inf the defense of the Holy City and determined to try to get through the Italians lines.” The next morning on the 19th, the group found another driver to take them closer to Rome. They followed the Piedmontese again and overtook their rear-guard. The Italian movement was called to a halt, the group kept continuing forward until they found themselves faced to face with General Bixio again, who seemed in no enviable mood, pacing to and fro on the roadway.

Bixio, frustrated to see them again asked “Why press on so eagerly with my army?”

The group responded “Our desire to be present at the operations”

Bixio shouted back at them:

But this is a war, a war! Your place on the march is at the rear and not in the midst of my troops. You enjoy the excitement of war? It's a small matter now. Those pet lions, the Zouaves, know how to fight; arising in the streets, we will place them between two fires! Their destruction is inevitable, as their presence in Rome is a menace and a danger to Italian patriots.

The persistence of the group however, caused General Bixio to acquis to their demands. He granted them permission to continue as far as his advanced post which was about two miles in front of them. He warned them to not pass through the lines, doing so would be out their own peril. The group continued, upon reaching the advanced line, a gathering of dragoons and bersaglieri posted near a ruined osteria told them to stop. The officer in command of the detachment of troops told the group that they should remain here and not proceed any further. Which O'Clery described as “another way of saying we were under arrest.”

This obstacle did not deter the small group of Papal Zouaves. Determined to carry on, they conceived a plan to fool the Italian soldiers holding them captive and escape. They asked the officers of the Italian detachment if they could get a better sight of Rome by climbing the heights just above the road. They left behind their luggage in the carriage with the exception of the satchel with papers and letters, in an effort to persuade the soldiers that they would be right back. The Italians bought the ruse, they made no objections and allowed the group to climb to the top, once there, Tracey, O'Clery, Kenyon, and Hermans discussed their next step:

Here we held a council in full view of the Piedmontese; the dragoons, with the exception of those acting as lookouts, were lounging in the shade, their horses picketed close by, our coachman was consoling himself with some water, the only thing to be had. Both my friends, Messrs. Tracey and Kenyon, through fully aware that the seizure of the dispatches would necessarily involve their fate in mine if captured, like true Zouaves unhesitatingly declared their readiness to accompany me at all hazards. At that moment, catching a glimpse of St. Peter's glorious dome in the distance, we could no longer brook delay, as we were only twelve miles from the Eternal City, and had given no parole to the Piedmontese. Turning the crest on the hill we descended rapidly and keeping along the valley, made a detour to avoid the road, as the dragoons cannot easily follow across country. Soon we left Bixio's army far behind us. Mile after mile we hurry on gaining fresh impulse at every step, as we see St. Peter's more and more clearly defined, towering in all its majesty against the sky. Not a sound disturbs the awful stillness which reigns around; it would indeed seem as if the world stood still before the commission of the dreadful crime on the morrow! But it is the calm which portends the storm; ere many hours elapse the cannonade will thunder far across the Campagne and make the shepherds cower in their huts on the slopes of the hills. On and on we press with an ardor fast becoming a fever of excitement, to reach the goal of our hopes, utterly regardless of the danger o falling in with Cadorna's cavalry scouts endeavoring to cut off communications with the devoted city.

After hours of travel, the group finally reached the Eternal City, arriving around 4 p.m., well ahead of the Italian forces. “Deo Gratias,” thought Kenyon “the yellow and white flag was still waving.” The Zouaves were enthusiastic that some of their former comrades had returned to help in the defense. They were quickly taken into the city. O'Clery summed up their feelings “Our hearts were full of gratitude for the privilege so signally accorded to us of being able to join our comrades before the assault.” Hermans at this point separated from the group. He wanted to remain just outside the city in order to observe the fight so he could report to his contacts in the London papers.

Once inside O'Clery handed off the papers himself to Cardinal Antonelli at the Vatican and the other papers he gave to Colonel Allet at the Zouave head-quarters on the Pincio. He was very happy to see some of his former Zouaves. O'Clery wrote that:

Our brave old commander welcomed us back to the corps with all that kindness of manner which has so endeared him to hearts of the Zouaves. As no news had reached the city for several days we reported to the affair at Civita Vecchia, the advance of Bixio's army, and the certainty of an attack on Rome next morning.

Tracey, Kenyon, and O'clery joined over 8,500 Papal soldiers who had made it inside the city during the general withdraw. The city was now surrounded by over 60,000 Italian soldiers, including a large contingent of Red Shirts who came to wreak havoc on the city.

The breach at Porta Pia during the fall of Rome, September 1870
A group of Papal Zouaves defending the breach at the Porta Pia

The 1870 Siege of Rome

Knowing that an attack was imminent Kanzler alongside General De Courten of the line infantry and General Zappi, went to Bl. Pius IX to petition him to allow a defense of the city instead of “surrender at first canon shot”. Bl. Pius IX was swayed and allowed a defense until “a breach has been opened” in the walls. Besides Kanzler, De Courten, and Zappi, the specifics of the orders and intentions were kept hidden from the rest of the officers and rank and file, they thought they were going to fight until the bitter end.

The Italian attack on Rome began in the early morning hours on September 20. The Papal Army put up a valiant resistance, taking “a breach in the walls” as loosely as possible. After several hours it became clear that a breach had been made. At 9:00 am Bl. Pius IX ordered the white flag to be flown over St. Peter's Basilica. He turned to the diplomats with him and said “Sirs, I give the order to surrender. Abandoned by all, I had to succumb sooner or later. I must not shed blood uselessly. You are my witnesses, Sirs, that the foreigner enters here only by force.”

There were many acts of heroism during this siege and the battle itself really deserves its own lecture. Through I would be remise if I didn't mention this particular story.

In the fog of war, the order to surrender wasn't disseminated or received well. Around 10:00 a.m. as a coureur was going to give the order to the officer in charge at the breach site itself at the Porta Pia. The Zouaves however, were too busy fending off three columns of Italian infantry that were in the midst of forming up to assault through the breach. When suddenly an Italian tri-color appeared out of a nearby tower. This was the signal for the Italian artillery to cease fire and for the infantry to begin the assault. The Papal guns stopped too and for a few seconds there was an eerie quiet on the battlefield. It was broken by the Papal Zouaves singing their regimental song. 300 voices sang out “Onward, onward, noble sons of France. Sons of Crusaders, it is God who guides you!” Captain Berger of the 4th Company 2nd Battalion rose and stood in the middle of the breach, pistol in one hand and his sword held aloft in the other as he sang along. When the song faded away silence returned. But that was quickly interrupted by cries of “Viva Pio Nono!” followed by a volley of 300 rifles. The bullets stopped the central Italian column of bersaglieri in its tracks.

After the surrender order and cease fire had been effectively promulgated, the Papal Army marched back to the Vatican to await further instruction. The crows of anticlerical and secret society members who had came in with the army accosted and even attacked the Papal Soldiers. Over the coming days, some were even murdered, and several churches and convents ransacked and destroyed. Near the Porta Pia was the worse, as Piedmontse soldiers ignored the ceasefire and stormed through the breach, catching many Zouaves off guard, killing them and stripping them of their medals.

The Papal Army departs St. Peter’s Square, September 21, 1870
The Papal Army departs St. Peter’s Square, September 21, 1870 Basilica

The End of an Era

The Papal Army spent the night bivouacked in St. Peter's Square. The following morning before the military was disbanded and everyone sent home, the Papal Army had one last formation and a final blessing was given by Bl. Pope Pius IX.

An Patrick Keyes O'Clery gave this account of the emotional scene:

When all the soldiers were lined up, facing the Vatican and ready to leave, Colonel Allet stepped forward and, his voice broken with emotion, shouted: “Mes enfants! Vive Pie Neuf!” A mighty cheer broke out from the troops. Just at that moment the Pope appeared on the balcony, and, raising his hands to heaven, prayed: “May God bless my faithful children!” The enthusiasm of that supreme moment was indescribable. With a frantic Eljen! (Hurrah) a Hungarian Zouave drew his sword, and immediately, with a simultaneous scuff of steel, thousands of unsheathed swords glinted in the sun. The scene was absolutely moving. At the thought of leaving the Holy Father, tears of bitter regret ran down the cheeks of those men who had defied death in so many desperate battles. The trumpets gave the order to advance and, as it moved, the head of the column let out a last sad cry of “Long live Pius IX!” which, echoed row after row, was repeated by the whole army and by the crowd gathered to watch the departure.
Flags representing the nationalities of the Papal Zouaves at the time of the Siege of Rome
Flags representing the nationalities of the Papal Zouaves at the time of the Siege of Rome

Final Count

The Papal Zouaves were put on a train and sent to Civita Vecchia. Under horrid conditions and lack of food they awaited to board steamers to return home. Thus the thousand year reign of the Papal States was over. The final composition of the regiment truly reflects the international makeup of the Papal Zouaves. The unit consisted of the following nationalities after Rome fell on September 20, 1870. 1,172 Dutch, 760 French, 563 Belgians, 297 Canadians, British, and Irish, 242 Italians from various states on the Peninsula, 113 Germans, 37 Spaniards, 19 Swiss, 15 Austrians, 7 Russians and Poles, 5 Americans, 4 Portuguese, 2 Brazilians, 2 Ecuadorian, 1 Peruvian, 1 Greek, 1 Monacan, 1 Chilean, 1 Ottoman Turk, and 1 Chinese. Not included were some nationalities who had finished service contracts with the unit and either failed to return to Rome before September 20 or had moved onto other things. These include but are not limited to Papal Zouaves from the Maltese, South Sea Islands, India, Africa, Mexico, and Circassia.

Having achieved victory, the new United Kingdom of Italy applied its anti-clerical laws of 1866 to Rome. Bl. Pius IX refused to acknowledge the takeover as legitimate. He considered himself a prisoner in the Vatican and refused to step outside its walls for the rest of his life. General Kanzler in solidarity adopted this same position. He retained his title as Minister of War honorarily. Subsequent popes remained as prisoners in the Vatican until the Lateran treaty in 1929 between Pope Pius XI and Mussolini, which formalized the relationship between Italy and the Vatican.

Portrait of a Papal Zouave veteran
Portrait of General Athanase de Charette at the Battle of Loigny December 2, 1870

Aftermath

For most of the Papal Zouaves, the fight was over. However, the majority of the French Papal Zouaves continued fighting with the unit as they reorganized under the new name the Volunteers of the West. The Volunteers fought to defend France during the remainder of the Franco-Prussian war. They are most well known for their bravery at the battle of Loigny Patay. On December 2, 1870 General de Sonis and Colonel de Charette led the unit in a 300-man charge against the Bavarians. They initially had the upper hand; however, no other French forces came to reinforce them. Upon realizing their true number, the Bavarians pushed them back. Out of the 300 in the charge, 218 died. Their flag had the image of the Sacred Heart of Jesus with the words, “Heart of Jesus save France.” After the war the unit was disbanded. Additionally, in 1873, many Papal Zouave veterans joined the Carlist Zouave Battalion under former Papal Zouave Prince Alfonso de Bourbon during the Third Carlist War. Many of the Papal Zouaves held onto hope that one day they would put on their uniform again and retake the Holy City for their beloved Pope. Unfortunately, these events never came to pass. The Papal Zouaves continued their fight against the Revolution in other ways. Such as through missionary efforts, writing in Catholic publications, participating in government, and starting Catholic businesses.

There’s far more to the Papal Zouaves than one page can hold — from Maximin Giraud, seer of Lasalette, to the alleged Lincoln conspirator John Surratt, to the American battalion that was planned but never raised. These stories, and so many others, deserve to be remembered. Help us uncover and share their history with the world. Become a member of Papal Zouave International and help carry their story forward.

Join the Cause